Tintin in the land of the Soviets
Came across this ‘lost’ Tintin book the other day, I hadn’t heard of it before so I was rather surprised when I came across it and picked it up. Why exactly this book has been ‘lost’ is beyond me – while it is the first book in the series, with the second being the ‘not-quite-banned but still’ ‘Tintin in the Congo’ it has fallen out of favor. Some of this is undoubtedly due to the fact that of the Tintin books these are perhaps two of the most dated, there is also a feeling that it may simply be just a result of a desire to ‘whitewash’ away the more raw edges Hérge’s work.
Regardless, the book isn’t anything terrible – it is clearly a less capable work, with the artwork nearly being unrecognizable due to the fact that it has not been recolored and so on and the story (what there is of one) is not up to much. In many ways it is simply a long piece of anti-Soviet propaganda with the vague plot simply just following Tintin around the USSR as he keeps ducking attempted assassination attempts from the Soviet Secret Services. The book establishes the standard style of Tintin being a very well regarded reporter despite the fact that he never gets any evidence or does any, you know, journalistic work! Also an oddity in the book is the complete lack of any attempt at realism – while later books would feature some dubious science and such like this book completely throws out such attempts. Within the pages Tintin fights (and beats) a bear and builds the propellers of an airplane! Also, how exactly such a crowd is there to welcome Tintin is beyond me.
The propaganda element is pretty serious within the book – while many of the elements of the propaganda have in a ‘stranger-than-fiction’ way turned out to be true (the rigged democracy, people starving at home while food is exported to give the impression of a healthy economy etc.) there are many spots where the way it is done is pretty insane – the worst one in my mind being the idea that Lenin Trotsky and Stalin have a hidden bunker with the people’s stolen wealth!
But all-in-all the book deserves a look, whether you read it as a fan of Tintin and want to see where he ‘came from’ so to speak or whether your a history student looking to see how the USSR was perceived even in its earliest days by some people. While the book is not required reading by any means its still quite interesting

